2020-2021
Trey Gibson - NCCAA Scholar-Athlete
2019-2020
Brandt Cochran - NAIA DII Honorable Mention All-American; NCCAA DI Third Team All-American
Trey Gibson - NCCAA Scholar Athlete
2018-2019
Ethan Davidson- NCCAA First Team All-American; NAIA Second Team All-American; NAIA and NCCAA Scholar Athlete
Heath Carmichael - NCCAA Scholar Athlete
Benjamin Cody - NCCAA Scholar Athlete
2017-2018
Heath Carmichael - NAIA and NCCAA Scholar Athlete
Ethan Davidson - NAIA and NCCAA Scholar Athlete
Ben Cody - NCCAA Scholar Athlete
2016-2017
Chandler Hall - Scholar Athlete (NAIA & NCCAA)
Cameron Paschke - NAIA DII Honorable Mention All-American; NCCAA Scholar Athlete
2015-2016
Chandler Hall - Scholar Athlete
Ethan Murray - NAIA DII Third Team All-American
Cameron Paschke - NAIA DII Honorable Mention All-American
Joe Young - Scholar Athlete
2014-2015
Derek Daniels - Honorable Mention All-American
Joe Young - Scholar Athlete
2013-2014
Nathane Simniok - NAIA DII Honorable Mention All-American
2012-2013
Mike Wiebe – NAIA DII Second Team All-American
2011-2012
Mike Wiebe – NAIA DII Second Team All-American
Weston Wiebe – Scholar Athlete
2010-2011
Mike Wiebe – NAIA DII Second Team All-American
Jared Howerton – NAIA DII Third Team All-American
Nathan Peterson – Scholar Athlete
Dustin Price – Scholar Athlete
2009-2010
Jared Howerton - NAIA DII All-American Honorable Mention
Nathan Peterson - Scholar Athlete
Dustin Price - Scholar Athlete
2008-2009
Tamas Papp - Scholar Athlete
Colt Blair - Scholar Athlete
Corey Stone - NAIA DII Third Team All-American
2007-2008
Daniel Bandy - NAIA DII Second Team All-American
Tamas Papp - Scholar Athlete
2006-2007
Michael Bonaparte - NAIA DII First Team All American
2005-2006
Michael Bonaparte - NAIA DII First Team All-American
Heath Sitton - NAIA DII Second Team All-American
2004-2005
Mark Schweitzer - Scholar Athlete
2003-2004
Mark Schweitzer - Scholar Athlete
Brandon Argo - NAIA DII All-American Honorable Mention
2002-2003
Josh Hume - NAIA DII All-American Honorable Mention
Trent Tremain - Scholar Athlete
2000-2001
Adam Cook - NAIA DII All-American Honorable Mention
Chris Waller - Scholar Athlete
1999-2000
Adam Cook - NAIA DII All-American Honorable Mention
Aaron Dalton - NAIA DII All-American First Team, Scholar Athlete
Chris Waller - Scholar Athlete
1998-1999
Aaron Dalton - Scholar Athlete
1996-1997
Todd Crighton - All-American Third Team
Zach Easterly - All-American Honorable Mention
1995-1996
James Wynn - All-American Honorable Mention
1994-1995
Brent Blevins - All-American Second Team
Mark Fultz - Scholar Athlete
1990-1991
Chris Larsen - All-American Honorable Mention
1983-1984
Mike Russell - All-American Honorable Mention
1982-1983
Mike Russell - All-American Honorable Mention